brightspark

growing out of SAD?

The Lumie forum is for general discussion of Seasonal Affective Disorder and all things light therapy. To join in you'll need to register.

We do not monitor this forum every day. If you want to reach Lumie please go to our contact us page.

Post reply Start new thread
JeanneinCanada
joined 8 Feb 2007
68 posts

send a pm

Posted by JeanneinCanada, 16:07 6 October 2007


I'm wondering (more hoping against hope really) if you've ever heard of someone getting better as they get older?

It seems most of us our youngish on here.


Jeanne
paulst
joined 5 Oct 2005
796 posts

send a pm

Posted by paulst, 18:25 6 October 2007

I really hope im wrong, but ive never heard of anyone growing out of sad, (im 51).I have felt low in the Winter for as long as I can remember, sorry its not much help.
JeanneinCanada
joined 8 Feb 2007
68 posts

send a pm

Posted by JeanneinCanada, 19:25 6 October 2007

I spent a few hours after posting this trying to find some evidence. largely futile though. As we know, we start in 20's usually and if its not treated, they tend to get worse.

I saw lots of the older you get the less likely you are to develop SAD, though men tend to start later than women, probably that slower development factor. I saw one vague reference that symptoms are lighter when older, but they didn't explain it at all. It could have meant that if you get it late in life its not as severe.

I was hoping that since it often starts at adolescence and hormones could play a role, that maybe menopause or even manopause could curb it too.


jeanne
Suzie
Suzie
joined 26 Jan 2007
438 posts

send a pm

Posted by Suzie, 20:19 6 October 2007

Hi Jeanne

I have suffered from it since my early 20's and unfortunately it has got worse as I have got older (i'm now 45). Here's hoping it changes with the menopause, something good has got to come out of that lol
rangers
joined 20 Dec 2006
47 posts

send a pm

Posted by rangers, 18:19 7 October 2007

on a visit to a sad a clinic i am sure the doctor told me that there is a chance a woman may grow out of it but not men
Patricia
Patricia
joined 31 Oct 2006
68 posts

send a pm

Posted by Patricia, 22:06 7 October 2007

I have had 'sad' since my teens and I am now 52, although it is really only in the last 10 years that I actually realised that it was 'sad', the only thing I have learnt is that I now know the signs and recognise when it is starting.
Hadrian
Hadrian
joined 11 Sep 2007
134 posts

send a pm

Posted by Hadrian, 00:08 8 October 2007

Mine started when I was 19,I'm now 37.Didn't know for certain it was SAD until last year-although I'd always had my suspicions.
Stained Glass Lady
joined 5 Dec 2007
423 posts

send a pm

Posted by Stained Glass Lady, 18:13 6 December 2007

Mine started when I was 45 and now I am 48 this is the first year they have said yes you have SAD
Amalthea
joined 12 Nov 2006
472 posts

send a pm

Posted by Amalthea, 21:37 6 December 2007

Mine started when I was 13 or so, now I'm 28. I'd say I'm learning to manage it better, but I don't know that it's easing up.

I'm living in hope that they'll figure this all out with research and there will be more effective treatments. Look at it this way, SAD wasn't recognized until what, when Rosenthal came around?

And it's still not widely recognized, imo.
Stained Glass Lady
joined 5 Dec 2007
423 posts

send a pm

Posted by Stained Glass Lady, 19:19 7 December 2007

I hope it changes with menopause geting close
JeanneinCanada
joined 8 Feb 2007
68 posts

send a pm

Posted by JeanneinCanada, 20:04 7 December 2007

I don't know if its because I'm Canadian, but SAD seems widely recognized here. It is known as a Northern malady and all. Though many seem to assume its a milder form of depression, and for many it is. For me its not mild or even medium once the ball gets rolling, nope, full blown paralyzing major depression, only the seasonal fairy brings it on.

I have to admit, I was surprised to find out its so common in Britain even though you guys endure so much rain and cloud. But I expected it more in places like Scandinavia, Russia, etc. And I also found out that you guys are actually a bit farther from the sun or a bit more northern latitude than me in Ottawa, Ontario.


Jeanne
Stained Glass Lady
joined 5 Dec 2007
423 posts

send a pm

Posted by Stained Glass Lady, 20:13 7 December 2007

Hi Jeanne in Ottawa I live in Ontario and most of the doctors know about SAD. You are right they just say its mild for of depression. For me its not now with the paxil I have to take epival for the moods. I don't like this but then you think spring is coming and there are only 15 more days till the days start to get longer. Also with the snow things look briter outside. I just wish we could get alittle snow. We had some but it melted.
JeanneinCanada
joined 8 Feb 2007
68 posts

send a pm

Posted by JeanneinCanada, 17:43 10 December 2007

Hi Stained Glass Lady,

Nice surprise to know I'm not the only Canadian. You jmust be in S. Ont. if your snow melted so soon. Ours came around 4 wks ago and hasn't left yet.


Jeanne
PurpleIvy
PurpleIvy
joined 16 Mar 2005
735 posts

send a pm

Posted by PurpleIvy, 20:02 10 December 2007

Stained glass lady, I got worse with the menopause (early menopause I hasten to add LOL!). In fact I was only diagnosed when perimenopausal.
Stained Glass Lady
joined 5 Dec 2007
423 posts

send a pm

Posted by Stained Glass Lady, 20:45 10 December 2007

I wish we still had snow it makes things alot briter. I hope it doesn't get worse with menopause. It is hard enough now.

Post a reply

Please note, this forum is for issues relating to SAD (Seasonal Affective Disorder) and light therapy.

The site is not monitored every day. Offensive posts, including those that blatantly promote products or services, will be removed but should you find something you dont like, please let us know.

To include working links in your post, use [url] at the start and [/url] at the end e.g. Have a look at [url]http://www.lumie.com[/url] for light therapy info

You can edit your message up to 15 minutes after posting.

Please send me an email when someone contributes to this discussion

Please note: submitting a comment will invite you to log in or register for free. Your comment will only display if you log in or register.

Forum terms and conditions.

Contact Us telephone 01954 780500