brightspark

clinical depression & SAD?

The Lumie forum is for general discussion of Seasonal Affective Disorder and all things light therapy. To join in you'll need to register.

We do not monitor this forum every day. If you want to reach Lumie please go to our contact us page.

Post reply Start new thread
birdie
joined 30 Dec 2007
1 posts

send a pm

Posted by birdie, 15:07 30 December 2007

Hi,

I was diagnosed as suffering from clinical depression in 1994. I have been on a succesful course of medication for many years, and have been able to live a pretty normal life.

The last few winters, however, I have been suffering from lenghthy bouts of symptoms - extreme lethargy, tiredness, lack of enthusiam, unsociability, and terrible difficulty leaving my bed.

The symptoms I suffered when depressed were more those of despair and deep anxiety.

I was wondering if anyone knows whether SAD can be considered as a separate condition, or one that could be experienced despite being successfuly treated for clinical depression with anti-depressants?

Thanks,

S
Faerie9
Faerie9
joined 13 Nov 2007
54 posts

send a pm

Posted by Faerie9, 21:03 30 December 2007

Hi Birdie
I think that the two can be considered separate, despite having similar symptoms. There are people with SAD who are just fine in the summer and only have symptoms in the winter. There are also people with depression all year round who are worse in the winter and also show different symptoms in the winter.

I'd have a word with your GP and tell him/her your concerns.

Best wishes
Fae
IrishMark
joined 27 Dec 2007
6 posts

send a pm

Posted by IrishMark, 22:46 30 December 2007

one can certainly have separate types of depression-bipolar, sad etc...
Jen
Jen
joined 1 Nov 2006
45 posts

send a pm

Posted by Jen, 22:57 30 December 2007

As far as Im aware, it's a separate condition but you could have it at the same time as suffering depression. I would speak to your doc about it & see what they say.
Linda
Linda
joined 15 Dec 2004
997 posts

send a pm

Posted by Linda, 11:06 31 December 2007

I have had clinical depression which has been exacerbated in the winter. It's entirely possible that you also are experiencing year-round depression which deepens at this time of year. It's also not unusual for the kinds of symptoms you have to surface after being on meds for a number of years.

Please take this in the spirit in which it is meant, which is purely to offer some heartfelt help. What the meds have been doing for you is controlling your symptoms. They are incapable of "curing" the root causes of depression and anxiety. Those root causes are still there from the sound of it. You can choose to continue to try to treat the symptoms, or you can address what is causing them. For most people it is usually a mix of nutritional/health and emotional factors. What is your overall health like and what is your diet like? Do you think there may be factors in your life, e.g. relationship or employment problems, which could be contributing to how you feel?

Just my two cents. Hope it helps.

Linda.

Post a reply

Please note, this forum is for issues relating to SAD (Seasonal Affective Disorder) and light therapy.

The site is not monitored every day. Offensive posts, including those that blatantly promote products or services, will be removed but should you find something you dont like, please let us know.

To include working links in your post, use [url] at the start and [/url] at the end e.g. Have a look at [url]http://www.lumie.com[/url] for light therapy info

You can edit your message up to 15 minutes after posting.

Please send me an email when someone contributes to this discussion

Please note: submitting a comment will invite you to log in or register for free. Your comment will only display if you log in or register.

Forum terms and conditions.

Contact Us telephone 01954 780500