brightspark

Should I buy? (13 Oct 02) 1 message

The Lumie forum is for general discussion of Seasonal Affective Disorder and all things light therapy. To join in you'll need to register.

We do not monitor this forum every day. If you want to reach Lumie please go to our contact us page.

Post reply Start new thread

Anonymous
joined 20 Nov 2008
45880 posts

send a pm

Posted by Anonymous, 16:10 20 October 2002

Should I buy?

posted by Mark Adams on 2002-10-13 09:58:42


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hi there,

My wife has suffered with chronic depression for many years and has always been treated with tablets. The depression does increase as the winter draws near. I am considering buying a SAD light box but wonder if somebody could advise:

A) What type of light? There seem to be choices of Natural Daylight or Bright White.

B) Is there a problem with 'Full Spectrum' light. I've read conflicting reports.

Any advice would be appreciated,

Thanks in advance,

Mark

Anonymous
joined 20 Nov 2008
45880 posts

send a pm

Posted by Anonymous, 15:25 5 December 2002

Mark.

Firstly, I'm sorry to hear about your wife; I hope that things improve.

In answer to your questions:

Natural daylight or bright white light?- Initial experiments with SAD concluded that full spectrum light was required to alleviate successfully the symptoms of SAD. More recent investigations however indicate that bright white light can be as effective, but only if the intensity is sufficient (typically 2,500 lux). Conclusion- light intensity is the most important consideration when buying a light box, or similar device.

Problems with full spectrum light- The research papers that I have read suggest that some side effects may be experienced by users of light therapy devices, regardless of the spectrum. These have included nausea, headaches and restlessness. However, I believe that the size of the population that reported these side effects was small and that they were often alleviated by increasing the distance between user and device.

Grandmother and sucking eggs and all that, but has your wife explored other avenues in terms of self-help? I'm thinking about regular, moderate exercise, relaxation, stress management, diet, socialising etc?

Best wishes,

Neville.

Post a reply

Please note, this forum is for issues relating to SAD (Seasonal Affective Disorder) and light therapy.

The site is not monitored every day. Offensive posts, including those that blatantly promote products or services, will be removed but should you find something you dont like, please let us know.

To include working links in your post, use [url] at the start and [/url] at the end e.g. Have a look at [url]http://www.lumie.com[/url] for light therapy info

You can edit your message up to 15 minutes after posting.

Please send me an email when someone contributes to this discussion

Please note: submitting a comment will invite you to log in or register for free. Your comment will only display if you log in or register.

Forum terms and conditions.

Contact Us telephone 01954 780500