The Lumie forum is for general discussion of Seasonal Affective Disorder and all things light therapy. To join in you'll need to register.
We do not monitor this forum every day. If you want to reach Lumie please go to our contact us page.
Posted by suave, 05:10 19 November 2006Hi, I'm the one that was driving to the sun. Well I did, but ran out of money and couldn't work there with no babysitter, so I came home. When I left, my husband was supportive and said he was putting in his transfer notice. But sometime while I was gone he started thinking I was making it all up. I came home to a destroyed house and have been getting worse everyday since I came home on Tues. I have my lightbox and have doubled my antidepressants from the summer dose. Yet I am still spending the day in bed while my kids have to fend for themselves. Then when my husband gets home I leave and go to a movie or sit in my car waiting for him to put the kids to bed. I just can't take them asking me for help and everything like I normally do without question in the summer. I feel so awful about missing six months a year with my kids, I could never put it into words. When my husband asked about dinner as I was leaving tonight and I shrugged my shoulders he looked discusted (and made sure I saw). I really hadn't even thought about it. They hadn't even had lunch for all I knew. In the summer I make sure they eat 3 healthy meals a day. Eating their fruits and veggies ect.....
When I called home later he told me this was just a sorry excuse for exteme laziness and I need to pull my self up. When I got home my daughter told me that daddy had said I was punishing him for not moving us to California. I know how damaging it is to worry the kids about our problems, I know. I just don't know what to do. I want to take the kids and go now, but still have no money to get started. This has been a very bad day ....again | |
Posted by Linda, 08:53 19 November 2006Suave, I was touched by your story. I think that all of us who have suffered depression can relate. And others don't really understand; it's not the sort of thing you can just explain is it. And as I'm sure you well know, depression is not a matter of being lazy.
My first question to you is: have you tried light therapy? If not, the best thing you can do for yourself is to start, now. If you have tried it and it hasn't helped, then please read on. I'd like to share with you some info I've had recently, from a lady who suffered deep depression and then went on to receive nerve damage from the antidepressant she was on and discontinued. She was a national-class runner and now can barely walk because of nerve damage in her feet. However, she is one of the most loving, positive people I know. She has a veritable library of really good self-help books. I know that you are looking for answers and don't want to be told to just read a book. But I think this one is very relevant to your situation, your problems, your feelings at the moment. The only thing I would ask you to do for now, if you read this book, is to put the idea of SAD on the back burner. Too many people come here citing SAD as the source of all their problems, and what this does is offer a ready excuse and scapegoat, when what they need to do is take control of their lives and become willing to make changes. I'm not saying SAD isn't real; but pure SAD can be mostly or totally lifted by light therapy. This is the belief of the doctor I am working with, and she has worked with depressed and mentally ill people for over 20 years. I myself was convinced I have SAD but now realise I do not. Here's a link to the book, if you'd like to have a look. I think it could really help you, if you feel ready to assess your own situation and make whatever changes you end up feeling you need: http://www.hgonline.co.uk/FMPro?-db=HG_Orders.fp5&-format=hgonline/shop/findbook.htm&ReqID=113&-new With love, Linda. | |
Posted by Linda, 09:31 19 November 2006Just a couple more things I thought of, though I don't want to overload you with info.
Antidepressants do not help many people. They can often make you feel worse in a lot of ways, especially if the dosage is increased. Can you connect any of the problems you're having now, e.g. sleepiness, emotional detachment etc, with the time when you increased your dose? Also, as many here know, I'm a big advocate of the power of nutrition to heal. Eating a wholefoods diet that cuts out sugar and simple starches and emphasises vegetables, protein and healthy fats, can go a long way toward healing the body. (Nutritional deficiencies can also cause mental illness, though often doctors don't think to look for this in a diagnosis; they're not trained even to think of it.) Some good supplements can help a lot too. As can exercise. What's important, I think, is to consider several approaches to depression, as it's so easy (and usually useless) to look for that one "magic bullet" that will make it all better. But it sounds to me like things are getting difficult in your family situation, and have been for some time, though it's been better in the summers. That's why the first thing I thought to mention to you is the link above to the book. It is published in the UK, not generally available in the US, but this site will ship to the US at a reasonable price. I hope this helps :) Please let us know how you get on. Linda. | |
Posted by PacificNorthwestPrisoner, 18:32 19 November 2006I just wanted to put in my two cents. I tried antidepressants, extreme light therapy (in lux and duration), negative ions, acupuncture, yoga, counseling, meditation, hypnosis, massage, tanning, vitamin D, all types of highly nutrative mood altering diets, and tons of supplements including 5-HTP/tryptophan and the other aminos that have shown promise for depression. The only thing that EVER worked for me was to leave town for the sun. We relocated for a year and I had a wonderful life for that time. We came home and I had my worst year ever. We've now moved permanently and I'm so incredibly happy. I still have a normal amount of problems, like everyone else, but I can deal with them, awake, alive and with a smile on my face.
I ended up checking back with the forum this year as a result of a private message from someone based on a post I wrote last winter. It's going to sound hard to believe, but I had almost forgotten already that I'd ever had a problem with SAD. I woke up and realized that it was already nearing the solstice and I hadn't even turned on my light box yet!!! Usually, it's out no later September 15 and doing me no good. I just wanted to share that even for what seemed like a hopeless case like me, there is truly hope. SAD can be cured, even if it requires moving for good. It was quite an upheaval in our lives and took 3 years to mastermind, but it was worth every bit of trouble and strain it caused because we're once again a happy family. My husband was asked to write a bit about what the experience is like for him. I'm going to start a new thread and post it there in the hopes that it will help others in similarly dire straights. | |
Posted by cotambear, 07:14 20 November 2006Antidepressants do not help many people.
By this I think/hope you mean that `For a large number of people antidepressants have not proved successful`? BECAUSE AD`s HAVE ACTUALLY HELPED LIFT MILLIONS OF PEOPLE OUT OF MISERY. Ok; 1. AD`s usually benefit around 1/3 of people in trials. I.e 1/3 have no response, 1/3 improve, but only to the level of those given the placebo control, and 1/3 have marked improvement above placebo. 1/3 is quite a low response rate really, but; 2. When non responders are switched to another AD, then 1/3 have a marked improvement, therefore; 3. It is prudent that those who are not benefiting from one type of AD should seek a doctors advice regarding switching to another, because; . 4. IT IS PROVING INCREASINGLY THE CASE THAT GETTING THE RIGHT ANTIDEPRESSANT FOR YOURSELF CAN BE A LONG PROCESS OF TRIAL AND ERROR. 5. Depression can be helped successfully by other means such as; a) counselling or cbt to challenge negative thoughts b) excluding medical causes like thyroid or anaemia problems. c) removing yourself from situational causes, (eg bad housing, abusive partners). d) lightboxes for SAD of course ;) 6. There are other promising areas of research such as vagus nerve stimulation and deep brain stimulation using electrodes. However; 7. These (AD`s, cbt etc.) are the only treatments that have been proved to be effective - Gimmicky Diets, Crystals, Feng Shui, and all the other mumbo jumbo at best gives someone a placebo benefit, and at worst relieves them of their cash and diverts them from real help. | |
Posted by siddy, 12:53 20 November 2006Hello,
what I would like to say is that although sad is making you feel bad you are most likely feeling more demoralised and depressed because things have not worked out and you feel unsupported by your husband. It's one thing to cope with sad on a personal level it's another to feel that you are not being supported or helped by the one who is supposed to love you. I think you need to try and get some dialogue going with your husband and let him know how unsupported you feel and that you want the situation to change. He is obviously going to feel resentful, maybe abandoned and feel he is trying to keep everything together. If you can both accept each others feelings maybe you can make some small changes to make the atmosphere in the home better and remind yourselves for the childrens sake you are discussing this. Maybe with better planning and discussion you might be able to relocate next year? best of luck | |
Posted by Linda, 16:36 20 November 2006Cotambear, I'm sorry but I can't let this slide, because it hits me rather personally, as well as the other people in my support group who have been on these drugs, been damaged by them, and managed a successful withdrawal only after a great amount of life adjustment and pain.
By saying that ADs work, you are spouting pharmaceutical propaganda. This "research" you cite, if you look deeper, is full of flaws all the way through the trials and the data analysis. Look at what Joel and I have been saying recently. Look up some of the sources I've quoted at various points throughout the forum over the past several months. Boosting neurotransmitter levels can help some people to feel better, at least temporarily, I have never refuted that. Heroin and cocaine can make you feel good too. This isn't to say that the cause of the problem is low levels of these chemicals, or that boosting them throughout the body is a healthy solution. I am still suffering long-term damage from coming off my SSRI last April. I recently mentioned a former national-class runner who can barely walk after taking the drugs. I could cite you a hundred other examples of people I know who have suffered drug damage. These drugs are HARMFUL. And going from one to another, trying to find one that "works," increases the stress and damage to the body. if you want to discuss this further, then by all means locate a topic elsewhere, where I've discussed this, or start one yourself; it's unkind to the lady who initially wrote in to be deviating from what she said. But be aware that if you say ADs are an effective treatment for depression, anywhere in this forum, i will challenge you. Linda. | |
Posted by suave, 18:34 20 November 2006Thank you so much everyone. PNP I can't thank you and your husband enough for your writings. Thank you Siddy too. My husband did apply for his transfer today. Its just a simple form online. He is being a little more understanding today. I pray it will last. So that, on top of a sunny day are helping a bit today. Linda, I want to thank you too for your imput. I do have to say though, I wrote this post with tears steaming down my face, in absolute desparation for someone to believe me. So it was a let down to read that you didn't think I had SAD. I thought "wow, even the SAD people don't believe me". I do know I have SAD. I just sometimes don't know how to describe this disorder to people. I really thank you all so much.
| |
Posted by Seasonally Apathetic & Disillusioned, 18:59 20 November 2006Hello Sauve. Thanks for sharing your good news, which I was very pleased to hear. I know the rest of this post is a bit late, but since I put a lot of work into it, I thought I would post it anyway:
It sounds like you are having a really rough time. Strangely, your posts got me thinking, and I’ve realised that every year I especially feel the need to flee around November. In the early years, before I realised I had SAD, I did try running away a few times. SAD can make us do irrational and desperate things. To try and escape, I went as far as: shoplifting supplies (got caught and cautioned by the police); stealing money from my parents (fell apart before I left, and owned up); and using a loan that I obtained fraudulently (dad helped me finally finish paying it off last year). I was young, and felt alone and scared, so reality usually set in before I actually got anywhere. Ironically, my plan was usually to head for the sun (like I subconsciously knew that I had SAD), but the time I got the furthest was using the loan money to follow up a shot at love in Austria – didn’t work out, due to it being SAD season. I might have actually had a better life if I had ever made it to Spain or somewhere sunny? However, I would have hated myself for stealing and cheating. Besides I wasn’t equipped with a good set of coping mechanisms to make it a reality, or to go it alone, in any case. I’ve only known for a couple of years that I have SAD, and reluctantly I seem to have no choice but to go abroad on my own. Literally I will have to start from scratch, but I am trying to do as much preparation as I can; which is difficult when most experts recommend that we refrain from making big decisions, whilst suffering from the effects of SAD. I don’t even have a partner or kids to worry about, so I cannot imagine how problematic the situation must be for you. My only advice is pretty much that of Siddy’s (Sorry for my SAD childish behaviour in the past Siddy.). I don’t have a family of my own, so I am probably not the best placed to give such advice. Nevertheless, as one caring human being to another: I think that you and your husband really need to sit down and have a proper talk, like proper adults. I was really pleased to read PacificNorthwestPrisoner’s story and the tale from her husband’s perspective, and I hope that you and your husband can learn something from it. It is time for you both to sort out what you are going to do for the interests of your own family unit. If you really love each other, then you will form a strategy together for the best way to proceed; whether it is trying to stay where you are and getting more help, or moving to California as a family. Above all, talk to each other honestly. You are not a terrible mom; if you were, you wouldn’t be worrying about being seen as one. However, you do need some love, support, and help. Don’t let SAD destroy your family; work together to prevent it. All the best Joel x | |
Posted by Linda, 21:04 20 November 2006Suave, I know how it must feel when people around you aren't taking your symptoms seriously. Depression can be one of the most painful conditions humankind can experience. I've been there, I can see you're there now, and there's no way I'd brush it aside. It is very real.
I'm not passing judgement on whether or not you have SAD. Very possibly you do. This is why I'd first suggest trying light therapy. If you have, and it didn't work, there are other things you can look into. If you know that making a move to a sunnier place would help you, if you truly know this, then maybe that's the path for you. Have you tried it out over a period of time? Others have left this forum to do that, with varying success. Some have never got back in touch, and maybe we can assume they're doing fine. At least one has gone back on antidepressants at her new home. Like others here have said, it's perhaps worth taking a long, clear look at your life as well, and asking yourself if there are problems here and now that are likely to follow you wherever you might go, and how you can start to deal with them now. I'm glad so many people have written in to support you, and I wish you all the best too, with whatever direction you decide to take. I couldn't hear someone writing in such obvious pain without doing my best to share what I've learned. I hope you're feeling better soon. Linda. | |
Posted by cotambear, 06:45 21 November 2006Dear Linda,
I will reply to the bulk of your submission later. However there is one point I will stress. Someone has come to this forum in clear distress. Someone who is currently under the care of (one presumes) of a doctor and is receiving anti depressant medication. I believe strongly that this person needs quickly to return to her doctor and get her medication reviewed. Beyond the empathy and love that has been shown her (by you Linda, admirably, and others), this is the most important piece of practical advice that can be given. However the strong slant of both your postings Linda was against this, implying that the symptoms were a result of the AD, citing nerve damage caused by AD`s, and proposing a treatment model based on diet. Linda you have of course the right to follow whatever new faddy diet you wish. But I will not allow your zeal for the latest cult of victimhood, `anti depressant survivors`, to cloud the issue of the immediate support that is needed. I will not post anymore in this thread, and Linda could we resume this discussion elsewhere. Dear Suave, please consider going back to your doctor and getting your medication reviewed - its not a `miracle cure`, but you might be helped. | |
Posted by megj, 15:41 21 November 2006Suave,
Go and see your doctor. Good case management is so important and your doctor needs to see you regularly if they have any chance of treating you properly (and yes, that is backed up by research!). I hope that you haven't upped your dose of ADs without consulting your doc...it's not necessarily the best idea. Can you and your husband work together on household issues, such as writing lists of things that need to be done each week? My boyfriend and I plan the week ahead each Sunday or Monday and it means that I don't have to think about food or shopping (thankfully he's the cook too, else I'd never eat a proper meal - no matter what time of year!). It makes a big difference to my week. It's sad that he's not 100% behind you on this, and it can be hard to explain to people that it's not simply a state of mind - hopefully he will come round if you can talk to him about it. I'm not passing judgement on whether or not you have SAD. Very possibly you do. This is why I'd first suggest trying light therapy. If you have, and it didn't work, there are other things you can look into. Linda, Suave's very first post mentions light therapy. I fully appreciate how passionately you believe in the path you and others like you have taken in dealing with SAD and other disorders, but please appreciate that everyone's path is different, recovery is and means different things to everyone. I was recently at a meeting where we were discussing the concept of recovery and one person was adamant that the medical model i.e. ADs was the only way to recover and across the table was one who advocating methods that avoided ADs at all costs. They were both users of mental health services who have recovered to differing degrees and can get on well with their lives, despite their opposite treatment regimes. | |
Posted by Linda, 20:40 21 November 2006We're funamentally disagreeing here Cotambear, though I thank you for your tactful response, at least regarding our support here of Suave (the 'victimhood' bit perhaps nonwithstanding).
Please go read the links/sources I recently posted on Antidepressant Info. You believe that I am trying to steer away from help-giving drugs and am offering namby-pambyism. What I'm doing is suggesting the very real possibility that the increased drugs may be part of the problem. Everyone knows ADs have side effects, and that they can increase when the dosage increases. I don't think many would dispute that. The error comes when the doctor decides that the deterioration in symptoms is instead due to a deterioration of the overall condition. A case in point that I know of. A teenager was put on Lexapro, a powerful SSRI, for depression. Her condition rapidly deteriorated to the point where the diagnosis of bipolar was added, and she was put on more drugs. Any sensible doctor should have considered that the Lexapro could have caused those problems. This is how people end up on cocktails of drugs, and it is not uncommon. The lady here can by all means consult her doctor. If the doctor is like most other doctors, he/she could suggest she maintain this dosage and give it time, or even increase the dosage, or try another med. Maybe he/she would suggest going back to the original dosage, though this is more rare. I suspect you would feel this is all a sensible approach. I do not. Again, before we say this is my opinion and I shouldn't be pushing it off on others, please do read some of the sources of info I've listed under Antidepressant Info. People here are telling me that we should all be free to pursue whatever we feel will help us. To each his own. However, if someone came on here saying they were . . . OK, let's use the idea again of getting drunk regularly, as a coping mechanism for depression. Would we all sit here, accept that, and tell this person "Good for you if it works"? I would question people's morals if they did that. Knowing how damaging psychotropic drugs are, I cannot according to my own moral code sit back and say "Great if it works for you," when I know these are drugs that damage the brain and the body. Let me emphasise, however, that the only thing I have said to Suave on the issue is that some of her difficulties could possibly stem from the increased dose of meds. BTW please ask me elsewhere about how I eat before you tell me I'm going down the new faddy diet route. Changing the way I eat, and taking quality supplements, saved my life. | |
Posted by suave, 06:47 22 November 2006Hi Everyone,
We have had 2 days of sun in a row. I started to work on this disaster of a house. Listened to 21 messages and attempted a few reply's on the phone. Apologized to the school for not showing up for my volunteering for a month, and told them I would try to be better. Thanks Megj. I made an apt. w/ a new doc. my friend goes to for her SAD. And yes we do need to get organized w/ our chores. That seems fine now, but lately on the gloomy days I am totally useless. Thank you all for being here. You are the only people I'm not afraid to talk to right now. | |





